ShowOn

Manual Flush Button Left of Undo Halves Misclicked Discards

A four-week trial shows moving the manual flush button left of undo halved misclicked discards, raising questions about interface design versus player error

Manual Flush Button Left of Undo Halves Misclicked Discards

Moving the manual flush control to the left of undo cut misclicked discards by roughly half in a four-week usability trial on a browser-based video poker client, according to the studio that ran it. The change is small enough to fit in a single line of UI code and large enough to show up in session logs. It also raises a question the industry has mostly avoided: how many "player errors" are actually interface errors?

The trial ran from February 3 to March 2, 2025, across 1,840 sessions on a Jacks or Better variant. The control layout was the only variable. In the control group, flush sat to the right of undo, the arrangement most clients still use. In the test group, the two swapped places. Both buttons kept the same size, color, and label.

What the numbers showed

Discards that were reversed within two seconds—the window the studio uses to define a misclick—fell from 4.1% of all discards in the control group to 2.2% in the test group. That is a 46% relative drop. The absolute figure matters more than the percentage: on a game where a player might discard 200 times an hour, the swap removes roughly four wrong clicks an hour.

The effect held across session length. Players in their first ten minutes showed the largest improvement, which fits the standard account of why this happens: experienced players build muscle memory for a layout, and new players do not yet have any.

Why position beats labeling

The studio's write-up points to proximity and motor pattern rather than confusion about what the buttons do. Undo and flush sit next to each other in nearly every client. Players who reach for undo after a bad hold are aiming at a target roughly 40 pixels wide. Putting flush in that slot means the reflex lands on a destructive action instead of a corrective one. Swapping the order does not make flush harder to find—it makes the wrong button harder to hit by accident.

No player in either group reported difficulty locating flush after the swap. The studio logged 11 support tickets during the trial, none about the new layout.

The regulatory angle

This is where the finding gets less comfortable for operators. In most U.S. regulated markets, the discard is treated as a player action, and reversing it is a courtesy the client extends. If a meaningful share of discards are misclicks caused by layout, the line between "player error" and "design defect" gets thin. State gaming divisions have not issued guidance on button placement, and it is not clear they want to.

There is also a commercial tension. A misclicked discard costs the player a hand, not the operator. Nothing in the trial suggests the swap changed hold patterns, session length, or spend. That makes it cheap to implement and easy to ignore.

What the trial did not test

The sample is one game, one jurisdiction's traffic, and a desktop client. Mobile layouts, where thumbs and smaller hit targets change the geometry, were excluded. The studio says a mobile run is planned but has not set a date. Nor did the trial isolate whether the gain came from the swap itself or from players noticing a change and slowing down—a novelty effect that could fade.

The obvious next test is whether the same swap helps on slot-style interfaces, where the equivalent of a misclicked discard is a spin at the wrong stake. If it does, the case for treating layout as a player-protection issue rather than a design preference gets harder to wave off.