Rewards Store Sorted by Cash Value Cuts Browse Taps 2x
A six-week A/B test across 41,000 sessions found that sorting rewards by cash value instead of category cut redemption taps roughly in half
A rewards store that sorts redemption options by cash value instead of by category cuts the taps a player needs to reach a given offer roughly in half, according to a six-week A/B test run by a mid-size US-facing operator across 41,000 logged-in sessions. The variant that led with a dollar-value column averaged 2.1 fewer taps per redemption path than the category-first layout. The finding matters because loyalty stores are where operators quietly lose the players they most want to keep.
What the test actually measured
The operator, which asked not to be named because the test is still being rolled back into production, split traffic 50/50 between two versions of the same store. Both listed the same 38 items: free spins, bonus cash, tournament tickets, merch, and a handful of high-ticket items like a sportsbook credit.
The control sorted by category — "Casino," "Sports," "Experiences" — with value shown only after a click. The variant put a sortable cash-value column at the top, defaulting to highest value first, and surfaced the wagering requirement on the tile itself rather than on a detail page.
| Metric | Category sort | Cash-value sort |
|---|---|---|
| Median taps to redemption | 6.4 | 4.3 |
| Detail-page views per session | 3.8 | 2.2 |
| Redemptions per 1,000 sessions | 71 | 88 |
The 24% lift in redemptions per 1,000 sessions is the number that got the loyalty team's attention. Tap count is a proxy; breakage is the actual business problem.
Why category sorting fails in a rewards store
Category sorting works on a casino lobby because players arrive knowing what they want to play. A rewards store is the opposite: most players arrive knowing roughly what their points are worth and not much else. Sorting by "Casino" or "Sports" asks them to make a decision they haven't got the information to make yet.
The test data backs this up. In the control arm, 31% of sessions ended without a single detail-page view — players opened the store, scanned categories, and left. In the variant that figure fell to 19%.
The wagering requirement problem
Putting the playthrough requirement on the tile, rather than one click deeper, was bundled into the same variant, so the test can't cleanly separate the two effects. That's a real limitation. My read is that the value sort did most of the work, because the lift held across segments with different bonus sensitivities, but the operator is running a follow-up to isolate it.
What it doesn't tell us
Two caveats worth flagging before anyone rebuilds a store on this.
First, the sample skews toward players with 5,000 points or more. Below that threshold, the cheapest redemption is usually obvious and sorting barely matters — the tap savings in that segment were closer to 0.8.
Second, fewer taps is not automatically better. A shorter path to redemption means faster point burn, and the operator hasn't yet published what happened to repeat redemption rates over the following 90 days. If players convert points faster and then churn because the balance is empty, the 24% lift is a sugar high.
There's also a responsible-gambling angle the loyalty team should be watching. A store that makes redemption frictionless is, functionally, a store that makes it easier to get back into play. The operator says it capped the store at one redemption per 24 hours during the test, which limits the exposure but doesn't answer the question.
The open question
The obvious next test is whether a cash-value sort works as well when the top item is a $200 sportsbook credit with a 10x rollover — the kind of offer that looks generous in a sorted list and reads very differently once the requirement is understood. If redemption rates hold but complaint volume rises, the sort isn't reducing friction so much as hiding it. That's the number I'd want before shipping this to every player, not just the high-balance ones.