ShowOn

One-Time Card Deposits Get 2x More First Top-Ups Than Wallets

One-time card deposits drive roughly twice the 30-day return rate of digital wallets among first-time players, with the gap holding across all stake levels

One-Time Card Deposits Get 2x More First Top-Ups Than Wallets

Players who make their first deposit with a one-time card—a virtual card number generated for a single transaction, or a prepaid voucher redeemed at checkout—come back for a second top-up at roughly twice the rate of players who fund through a digital wallet. That gap shows up within the first 30 days and holds across stake levels, according to operator-side data shared with iGaming Business Review by two payment processors that asked not to be named because the figures are under client contract.

The comparison covers first-time depositors at US-licensed sportsbooks and casino apps between January and March 2024. Among card-voucher depositors, 41.6% made a second deposit within 30 days; among e-wallet depositors, the figure was 21.3%. Neither group was offered a reload bonus in the window, which removes the most obvious confound.

Why the Card Cohort Behaves Differently

Payment analysts point to three overlapping explanations, none of which fully accounts for the gap on its own.

The prepaid mindset

A player who buys a $50 card at a drugstore has already committed the money before opening the app. That sunk cost changes the psychology of the first session: the deposit feels like spending, not transferring. Players who fund from a wallet, by contrast, often treat the balance as an extension of their bank account and can reverse the decision by simply not returning.

Fewer friction points on deposit two

Wallets are supposed to win on convenience, and they do—after setup. The problem is the setup itself. A new wallet account requires identity verification, sometimes a bank link, and a wait of a day or more before funds are usable. Card vouchers skip all of it. The second deposit is just another trip to the same retailer or a saved virtual card number.

Bonus eligibility

Several US operators exclude prepaid and voucher methods from deposit-match promotions, which seems counterintuitive given the retention numbers. One processor's data showed card-voucher players who did receive a match bonus converted to a third deposit at 58%, the highest of any payment group in the sample.

The Numbers Behind the Claim

The 2x figure is not uniform. It narrows sharply at higher deposit sizes. Below $100, the 30-day repeat rate for card vouchers was 44.1% versus 19.8% for wallets—a ratio of 2.2x. Between $100 and $500, the gap compressed to 1.4x. Above $500, wallets actually edged ahead, 33.2% to 29.7%, likely because high-value players gravitate toward methods with faster withdrawal paths.

Geography matters too. The card advantage was strongest in states where retail prepaid cards are widely available—Ohio, Pennsylvania, and Michigan all showed ratios above 2x—and weakest in states with restrictive card-purchase rules.

What Operators Are Doing With It

At least three US-licensed operators have quietly added voucher redemption to their first-deposit flow since the data circulated, and one has begun testing a "buy again" prompt that surfaces the nearest retail locations after a player's first session ends. Payment processors, meanwhile, are pushing virtual single-use cards as a middle ground: the same one-time psychology, but issued inside the app.

The open question is whether the effect survives scale. Card vouchers carry higher processing costs and lower average deposit sizes than wallets, and the players they attract may simply be earlier in their betting lifecycle—more likely to make a second deposit because they have less experience to discourage them. If the 2x holds only for newcomers, operators chasing lifetime value may find the wallet cohort, despite its slower start, is the one worth subsidizing.